George Simmons Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 Hi All,I finally figured out how many CAT5 cables and lenghths I needed and went looking around for them yesterday. OUCH!! I guess while I wasn't paying attention the last couple of years, the prices have gone through the roof!Does anyone have any advice where a fellow can purchase them for a reasonable price? I tried the usual culprits - Best Buy, etc, and the best price I found was at Radio Shack - which was still outrageous by my standards.Advice anyone?George
Anthony in Houston Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 II had to use various lengths of the cat5 cables and the best solution I came up with was to putchase the cable in bulk 300 or longer bulk length and make the cables to length.At one time Fries Electronics had th 300 foot cable bulk with crimpers and ends for $39.I used this in my display and was able to make runs that did not waste cable. Look for a package like this at your local electronics stores.AnthonyRidding out hurricane Ike at work for the next 2 days and keeping fire trucks going and going like the energizer bunny.
doublea Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 George Simmons wrote: Hi All,I finally figured out how many CAT5 cables and lenghths I needed and went looking around for them yesterday. OUCH!! I guess while I wasn't paying attention the last couple of years, the prices have gone through the roof!Does anyone have any advice where a fellow can purchase them for a reasonable price? I tried the usual culprits - Best Buy, etc, and the best price I found was at Radio Shack - which was still outrageous by my standards.Advice anyone?GeorgeI assume you dont know of any local electronics store? Locally owned stroes usually have the best deals on this stuff. I found my 100ft cord for 8.99 at my local store.I assume you dont want to use phone cable to link your lor controlers?I would also give newegg.com a try -http://www.newegg.com/Store/SubCategory.aspx?SubCategory=132&name=Network-Cableshttp://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16812189039
RI_Pilot Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 Parts Express has a buy out on various lengths of patch cables. For example they have a 50 foot Cat5E snagless patch cable for $5.88, 25 foot for $3.48. Short lengths are less than $2. I stocked up on various lengths earlier this year. I have an extensive home network and use a lot of cables.www.partsexpress.comGo to the Wire/Cable category and look at Home A/V Cat 5/6 cables.Howard
doublea Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 RI_Pilot wrote: Parts Express has a buy out on various lengths of patch cables. For example they have a 50 foot Cat5E snagless patch cable for $5.88, 25 foot for $3.48. Short lengths are less than $2. I stocked up on various lengths earlier this year. I have an extensive home network and use a lot of cables.http://www.partsexpress.comGo to the Wire/Cable category and look at Home A/V Cat 5/6 cables.Howardbeats the pants of newegg thats for sure I think my bookmark toolbar found a new button too
Tim Fischer Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 Seems that most folks here use Cat5, but for 5 seasons (going on 6) I've exclusively used flat phone cord -- the type which you can buy 50' lengths for a buck or two.Used it with 144 channels and going possibly 1000' of wire last year, planning on adding 32 channels this year (but not much more wire as they'll drop inline).If you want Cat5, and have anything over a couple of controllers, I'd buy bulk wire and make up your own. A good crimper runs about $50 (don't cheap out on this -- I tried and failed miserably) and you'll pay that off in just a few crimps... The Ideal brand sold at Home Depot is what I now have, and it works very well with both Cat5 and phone (most of what I've done with it is phone, although I've done some Cat5 for home networking use).Good luck,-Tim
George Simmons Posted September 12, 2008 Author Posted September 12, 2008 Thanks guys.Tim - I've thought of using flat phone cable since I probably have enough of 'em laying around to wrap around my house two or three times. But how do you daisy-chain the controllers since they have only one receptacle for telephone cable? Do you use splitters to feed just one cable to each controller?Howard - Thanks for the link to partsexpress. Those are the kinds of CAT5 prices I remember seeing the last time I bought any. Sheesh... Radio Shack had a price of $36 bucks for a 50' cable and proudly proclaimed they had the lowest price in town - which in my travels, they did! I'm glad I asked the question here - you've taken a big load off my mind and wallet. Hmmm... I wonder if I can parlay the "savings" on cable as an excuse for buying another controller???George
Tim Fischer Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 George Simmons wrote: Thanks guys.Tim - I've thought of using flat phone cable since I probably have enough of 'em laying around to wrap around my house two or three times. But how do you daisy-chain the controllers since they have only one receptacle for telephone cable? Do you use splitters to feed just one cable to each controller?George,The "out" jack fits either a phone or network cable, so you can daisy chain at will. The only reason LOR has two different input connectors is that phone cords are wired as "crossover" whereas standard network cables are wired straight through.(as a bit of trivia, the original LOR boards, of which I have something like 72 channels of, had just two Cat-5 connectors, and you had to use jumpers to select "standard" or "crossover"...)You can even mix Cat-5 and phone in the same LOR network.-Tim
Denny Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 I have mixed cat5 and phone cords every year without problem. I initially used phone cord because, at the time, it was cheaper than cat5. I figured someone would trip over the cord (most likely me) and break it. Cheaper to replace a phone cord than a cat5. Each year, I buy enough cat5 to retire the phone cords, but then Dan comes up with these terrific sales each year and I end up with more controllers, so the phone cords continue to be used.
George Simmons Posted September 12, 2008 Author Posted September 12, 2008 Thanks Tim. Heaven forbid I should actually READ the full instruction manual...Thanks again everyone for the info.
Tim Fischer Posted September 13, 2008 Posted September 13, 2008 George Simmons wrote: Thanks Tim. Heaven forbid I should actually READ the full instruction manual...If you saw my thread about how I installed eight optoisolator chips upside-down on my kit, you'll see I fully understand... :?-Tim
George Simmons Posted September 16, 2008 Author Posted September 16, 2008 Tim or ?,One last question. I've got nine controllers on a small city lot. From my "office" window at home where the CPU running the show is located I'll have controllers in two opposite directions - six one way and three the other. Can I feed an ordinary phone cable to the controller closest to the window and then branch out in two directions from that unit with Cat5? Or do I have to connect them all in a straight line, so to speak?Okay, I guess that was two questions.Thanks.George
Tim Fischer Posted September 16, 2008 Posted September 16, 2008 George Simmons wrote: Tim or ?,One last question. I've got nine controllers on a small city lot. From my "office" window at home where the CPU running the show is located I'll have controllers in two opposite directions - six one way and three the other. Can I feed an ordinary phone cable to the controller closest to the window and then branch out in two directions from that unit with Cat5? Or do I have to connect them all in a straight line, so to speak?Okay, I guess that was two questions.Thanks.GeorgeWith a standard interface, you're supposed to have them all in one straight chain (electrically). That's what I do, even though in a couple of places the wire goes to a controller, then the output wire doubles back on that one to get to the next physical locations...I believe there is now a newer computer interface that has two ports on it so you can run the network in two directions -- I have no experience with it but I"m sure it works as advertised.-Tim
Guest wbottomley Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 You can use a repeater that LOR has recently put on their line of accessories: http://store.lightorama.com/rsnere.htmlIt has one input and two outputs.
Alan Roten Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 MPJA has good prices on cat 5 cable. They have 50 ft cables for $2.95 and 100 ft cables for $9.95. 50 ft http://www.mpja.com/prodinfo.asp?number=13695+TT100 ft http://www.mpja.com/prodinfo.asp?number=16951+TTThey also have short ones for less than $1.00 I have ordered from them before andshipping is reasonable. They do have a $15.00 min order
JBullard Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 Mountainwxman wrote: You can use a repeater that LOR has recently put on their line of accessories: http://store.lightorama.com/rsnere.htmlIt has one input and two outputs.William,I bought one of those this year, in testing with 16 controllers, works great! Gives a lot of flexibility in arranging the controllers in the yard.Look forward to seeing you again next week at the Charlotte, NC mini. Don't forget to bring the "gasoline additive". I'm bringing plenty of red "funnels".
Steven Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 George Simmons wrote: Can I feed an ordinary phone cable to the controller closest to the window and then branch out in two directions from that unit with Cat5? Or do I have to connect them all in a straight line, so to speak? Yes, you have to connect them all in a straight line, but the computer can be in the middle of this straight line. In other words, a RS485 (LOR) network must have exactly two ends. Many setups have one end at the computer and the other end at the "last" controller, but in your case (and in mine, by the way), it makes more sense to have one end on the controller at one end of your lot and the other end on the controller at the other end of your lot, with the computer in the middle.Normally, if you want to put the computer in the middle, you will use the RS485 Adapter with Booster (store.lightorama.com/uscoadwivobo.html) because it has two RJ45 jacks, but both RJ45 jacks are wired in parallel, so it's possible to run two cables from one of the RS485 adapters with one RJ45, if you don't mind a messy splice.
Guest wbottomley Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 JBullard wrote: Mountainwxman wrote: You can use a repeater that LOR has recently put on their line of accessories: http://store.lightorama.com/rsnere.htmlIt has one input and two outputs.William,I bought one of those this year, in testing with 16 controllers, works great! Gives a lot of flexibility in arranging the controllers in the yard.Look forward to seeing you again next week at the Charlotte, NC mini. Don't forget to bring the "gasoline additive". I'm bringing plenty of red "funnels".John, I have 20 controllers this year. But I'm running two legs from my MP3 Director card.Hopefully I won't need one.The gas-a-haul will arrive safe and sound, hopefully.
Tim Fischer Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 Steven wrote: so it's possible to run two cables from one of the RS485 adapters with one RJ45, if you don't mind a messy splice.In the past, Dan's discouraged people from doing that (and that was before he sold a dual-jack option so I don't think he had alterior motives ) due to potential network reliability issues. But I'm pretty sure people have gotten it working...I'm lucky that I'm able to basically come up with a very-meandering chain of controllers. I do have one place (as I mentioned above) which is sort of an extension, where the wire runs out to two controllers, then doubles back on itself and runs the other direction... You can run a lot of extra wire before you recoup the costs of a repeater or double-jacked interface (although when I eventually upgrade my ancient LOR PC I may well invest in the dual-jacked USB solution to replace my 1st-gen serial adapter...)-Tim
JBullard Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 Mountainwxman wrote: JBullard wrote: Mountainwxman wrote: You can use a repeater that LOR has recently put on their line of accessories: http://store.lightorama.com/rsnere.htmlIt has one input and two outputs.William,I bought one of those this year, in testing with 16 controllers, works great! Gives a lot of flexibility in arranging the controllers in the yard.Look forward to seeing you again next week at the Charlotte, NC mini. Don't forget to bring the "gasoline additive". I'm bringing plenty of red "funnels".John, I have 20 controllers this year. But I'm running two legs from my MP3 Director card.Hopefully I won't need one.The gas-a-haul will arrive safe and sound, hopefully.I'll still use my 3 ELLs with my display, to keep from running CAT5 across the driveway and sidewalks.
Recommended Posts